Simulations of Biological Systems
Multi-Physics Models of Cancer Cells
UncertainSCI: A Python Package for Noninvasive Parametric Uncertainty Quantification of Simulation Pipelines|
J. Tate, Z. Liu, J.A. Bergquist, S. Rampersad, D. White, C. Charlebois, L. Rupp, D. Brooks, R. MacLeod, A. Narayan. In Journal of Open Source Software, Vol. 8, No. 90, 2023.
We have developed UncertainSCI (UncertainSCI, 2020) as an open-source tool designed to make modern uncertainty quantification (UQ) techniques more accessible in biomedical simulation applications. UncertainSCI is implemented in Python with a noninvasive interface to meet our software design goals of 1) numerical accuracy, 2) simple application programming interface (API), 3) adaptability to many applications and methods, and 4) interfacing with diverse simulation software. Using a Python implementation in UncertainSCI allowed us to utilize the popularity and low barrier-to-entry of Python and its common packages and to leverage the built-in integration and support for Python in common simulation software packages and languages. Additionally, we used noninvasive UQ techniques and created a similarly noninvasive interface to external modeling software that can be called in diverse ways, depending on the complexity and level of Python integration in the external simulation pipeline. We have developed and included examples applying UncertainSCI to relatively simple 1D simulations implemented in Python, and to bioelectric field simulations implemented in external software packages, which demonstrate the use of UncertainSCI and the effectiveness of the architecture and implementation in achieving our design goals. UnceratainSCI differs from similar software, notably UQLab, Uncertainpy, and Simnibs, in that it can be efficiently and non-invasively used with external simulation software, specifically with high resolution 3D simulations often used in Bioelectric field simulations. Figure 1 illustrates the use of UncertainSCI in computing UQ with modeling pipelines for bioelectricity simulations
A Grid Search of Fibrosis Thresholds for Uncertainty Quantification in Atrial Flutter Simulations|
B.A. Orkild, J.A. Bergquist, E.N. Paccione, M. Lange, E. Kwan, B. Hunt, R. MacLeod, A. Narayan, R. Ranjan. In Computing in Cardiology, 2023.
Atypical Atrial Flutter (AAF) is the most common cardiac arrhythmia to develop following catheter ablation for atrial fibrillation. Patient-specific computational simulations of propagation have shown promise in prospectively predicting AAF reentrant circuits and providing useful insight to guide successful ablation procedures. These patient-specific models require a large number of inputs, each with an unknown amount of uncertainty. Uncertainty quantification (UQ) is a technique to assess how variability in a set of input parameters can affect the output of a model. However, modern UQ techniques, such as polynomial chaos expansion, require a well-defined output to map to the inputs. In this study, we aimed to explore the sensitivity of simulated reentry to the selection of fibrosis threshold in patient-specific AAF models. We utilized the image intensity ratio (IIR) method to set the fibrosis threshold in the LGE-MRI from a single patient with prior ablation. We found that the majority of changes to the duration of reentry occurred within an IIR range of 1.01 to 1.39, and that there was a large amount of variability in the resulting arrhythmia. This study serves as a starting point for future UQ studies to investigate the nonlinear relationship between fibrosis threshold and the resulting arrhythmia in AAF models.
Uncertainty quantification of the effect of cardiac position variability in the inverse problem of electrocardiographic imaging|
J. A. Bergquist, B. Zenger, L. Rupp, A. Busatto, J. D. Tate, D. H. Brooks, A. Narayan, R. MacLeod. In Journal of Physiological Measurement, IOP Science, 2023.
Electrocardiographic imaging (ECGI) is a functional imaging modality that consists of two related problems, the forward problem of reconstructing body surface electrical signals given cardiac bioelectric activity, and the inverse problem of reconstructing cardiac bioelectric activity given measured body surface signals. ECGI relies on a model for how the heart generates bioelectric signals which is subject to variability in inputs. The study of how uncertainty in model inputs affects the model output is known as uncertainty quantification (UQ). This study establishes develops, and characterizes the application of UQ to ECGI.
We establish two formulations for applying UQ to ECGI: a polynomial chaos expansion (PCE) based parametric UQ formulation (PCE-UQ formulation), and a novel UQ-aware inverse formulation which leverages our previously established ``joint-inverse" formulation (UQ joint-inverse formulation). We apply these to evaluate the effect of uncertainty in the heart position on the ECGI solutions across a range of ECGI datasets.
We demonstrated the ability of our UQ-ECGI formulations to characterize the effect of parameter uncertainty on the ECGI inverse problem. We found that while the PCE-UQ inverse solution provided more complex outputs such as sensitivities and standard deviation, the UQ joint-inverse solution provided a more interpretable output in the form of a single ECGI solution. We find that between these two methods we are able to assess a wide range of effects that heart position variability has on the ECGI solution.
This study, for the first time, characterizes in detail the application of UQ to the ECGI inverse problem. We demonstrated how UQ can provide insight into the behavior of ECGI using variability in cardiac position as a test case. This study lays the groundwork for future development of UQ-ECGI studies, as well as future development of ECGI formulations which are robust to input parameter variability.
Nascent adhesions shorten the period of lamellipodium protrusion through the Brownian ratchet mechanism|
K.R. Carney, A.M. Khan, S. Stam, S.C. Samson, N. Mittal, S. Han, T.C. Bidone, M. Mendoza. In Mol Biol Cell, 2023.
Directional cell migration is driven by the conversion of oscillating edge motion into lasting periods of leading edge protrusion. Actin polymerization against the membrane and adhesions control edge motion, but the exact mechanisms that determine protrusion period remain elusive. We addressed this by developing a computational model in which polymerization of actin filaments against a deformable membrane and variable adhesion dynamics support edge motion. Consistent with previous reports, our model showed that actin polymerization and adhesion lifetime power protrusion velocity. However, increasing adhesion lifetime decreased the protrusion period. Measurements of adhesion lifetime and edge motion in migrating cells confirmed that adhesion lifetime is associated with and promotes protrusion velocity, but decreased duration. Our model showed that adhesions’ control of protrusion persistence originates from the Brownian ratchet mechanism for actin filament polymerization. With longer adhesion lifetime or increased adhesion density, the proportion of actin filaments tethered to the substrate increased, maintaining filaments against the cell membrane. The reduced filament-membrane distance generated pushing force for high edge velocity, but limited further polymerization needed for protrusion duration. We propose a mechanism for cell edge protrusion in which adhesion strength regulates actin filament polymerization to control the periods of leading edge protrusion.
Multi-Omic Integration of Blood-Based Tumor-Associated Genomic and Lipidomic Profiles Using Machine Learning Models in Metastatic Prostate Cancer|
S. Fang, S. Zhe, H.M. Lin, A.A. Azad, H. Fettke, E.M. Kwan, L. Horvath, B. Mak, T. Zheng, P. Du, S. Jia, R.M. Kirby, M. Kohli. In Clinical Cancer Informatics, 2023.
Computational model of integrin adhesion elongation under an actin fiber|
S. Campbell, M. C. Mendoza, A. Rammohan, M. E. McKenzie, T. C. Bidone. In PLOS Computatonal Biology, Vol. 19, No. 7, Public Library of Science, pp. 1-19. 7, 2023.
Cells create physical connections with the extracellular environment through adhesions. Nascent adhesions form at the leading edge of migrating cells and either undergo cycles of disassembly and reassembly, or elongate and stabilize at the end of actin fibers. How adhesions assemble has been addressed in several studies, but the exact role of actin fibers in the elongation and stabilization of nascent adhesions remains largely elusive. To address this question, here we extended our computational model of adhesion assembly by incorporating an actin fiber that locally promotes integrin activation. The model revealed that an actin fiber promotes adhesion stabilization and elongation. Actomyosin contractility from the fiber also promotes adhesion stabilization and elongation, by strengthening integrin-ligand interactions, but only up to a force threshold. Above this force threshold, most integrin-ligand bonds fail, and the adhesion disassembles. In the absence of contraction, actin fibers still support adhesions stabilization. Collectively, our results provide a picture in which myosin activity is dispensable for adhesion stabilization and elongation under an actin fiber, offering a framework for interpreting several previous experimental observations.
Editorial: Image-based computational approaches for personalized cardiovascular medicine: improving clinical applicability and reliability through medical imaging and experimental data|
S. Pirola, A. Arzani, C. Chiastra, F. Sturla. In Frontiers in Medical Technology, Vol. 5, 2023.
|Halide Code Generation Framework in Phylanx,
R. Tohid, S. Shirzad, C. Taylor, S.A. Sakin, K.E. Isaacs, H. Kaiser. In Euro-Par 2022: Parallel Processing Workshops, Springer Nature Switzerland, pp. 32--45. 2023.
Separating algorithms from their computation schedule has become a de facto solution to tackle the challenges of developing high performance code on modern heterogeneous architectures. Common approaches include Domain-specific languages (DSLs) which provide familiar APIs to domain experts, code generation frameworks that automate the generation of fast and portable code, and runtime systems that manage threads for concurrency and parallelism. In this paper, we present the Halide code generation framework for Phylanx distributed array processing platform. This extension enables compile-time optimization of Phylanx primitives for target architectures. To accomplish this, (1) we implemented new Phylanx primitives using Halide, and (2) partially exported Halide's thread pool API to carry out parallelism on HPX (Phylanx's runtime) threads. (3) showcased HPX performance analysis tools made available to Halide applications. The evaluation of the work has been done in two steps. First, we compare the performance of Halide applications running on its native runtime with that of the new HPX backend to verify there is no cost associated with using HPX threads. Next, we compare performances of a number of original implementations of Phylanx primitives against the new ones in Halide to verify performance and portability benefits of Halide in the context of Phylanx.
Multiscale models of integrins and cellular adhesions|
T.C. Bidone, D.J. Odde. In Current Opinion in Structural Biology, Vol. 80, Elsevier, 2023.
Computational models of integrin-based adhesion complexes have revealed important insights into the mechanisms by which cells establish connections with their external environment. However, how changes in conformation and function of individual adhesion proteins regulate the dynamics of whole adhesion complexes remains largely elusive. This is because of the large separation in time and length scales between the dynamics of individual adhesion proteins (nanoseconds and nanometers) and the emergent dynamics of the whole adhesion complex (seconds and micrometers), and the limitations of molecular simulation approaches in extracting accurate free energies, conformational transitions, reaction mechanisms, and kinetic rates, that can inform mechanisms at the larger scales. In this review, we discuss models of integrin-based adhesion complexes and highlight their main findings regarding: (i) the conformational transitions of integrins at the molecular and macromolecular scales and (ii) the molecular clutch mechanism at the mesoscale. Lastly, we present unanswered questions in the field of modeling adhesions and propose new ideas for future exciting modeling opportunities.
Protein-metabolite interactomics of carbohydrate metabolism reveal regulation of lactate dehydrogenase|
K. G. Hicks, A. A. Cluntun, H. L. Schubert, S. R. Hackett, J. A. Berg, P. G. Leonard, M. A. Ajalla Aleixo, Y. Zhou, A. J. Bott, S. R. Salvatore, F. Chang, A. Blevins, P. Barta, S. Tilley, A. Leifer, A. Guzman, A. Arok, S. Fogarty, J. M. Winter, H. Ahn, K. N. Allen, S. Block, I. A. Cardoso, J. Ding, I. Dreveny, C. Gasper, Q. Ho, A. Matsuura, M. J. Palladino, S. Prajapati, P. Sun, K. Tittmann, D. R. Tolan, J. Unterlass, A. P. VanDemark, M. G. Vander Heiden, B. A. Webb, C. Yun, P. Zhap, B. Wang, F. J. Schopfer, C. P. Hill, M. C. Nonato, F. L. Muller, J. E. Cox, J. Rutter. In Science, Vol. 379, No. 6636, pp. 996-1003. 2023.
Metabolic networks are interconnected and influence diverse cellular processes. The protein-metabolite interactions that mediate these networks are frequently low affinity and challenging to systematically discover. We developed mass spectrometry integrated with equilibrium dialysis for the discovery of allostery systematically (MIDAS) to identify such interactions. Analysis of 33 enzymes from human carbohydrate metabolism identified 830 protein-metabolite interactions, including known regulators, substrates, and products as well as previously unreported interactions. We functionally validated a subset of interactions, including the isoform-specific inhibition of lactate dehydrogenase by long-chain acyl–coenzyme A. Cell treatment with fatty acids caused a loss of pyruvate-lactate interconversion dependent on lactate dehydrogenase isoform expression. These protein-metabolite interactions may contribute to the dynamic, tissue-specific metabolic flexibility that enables growth and survival in an ever-changing nutrient environment. Understanding how metabolic state influences cellular processes requires systematic analysis of low-affinity interactions of metabolites with proteins. Hicks et al. describe a method called MIDAS (mass spectrometry integrated with equilibrium dialysis for the discovery of allostery systematically), which allowed them to probe such interactions for 33 enzymes of human carbohydrate metabolism and more than 400 metabolites. The authors detected many known and many new interactions, including regulation of lactate dehydrogenase by ATP and long-chain acyl coenzyme A, which may help to explain known physiological relations between fat and carbohydrate metabolism in different tissues. —LBR A mass spectrometry and dialysis method detects metabolite-protein interactions that help to control physiology.
Contribution of atrial myofiber architecture to atrial fibrillation|
R. Kamali, E. Kwan, M. Regouski, T.J. Bunch, D.J. Dosdall, E. Hsu, R. S. Macleod, I. Polejaeva, R. Ranjan. In PLOS ONE, Vol. 18, No. 1, Public Library of Science, pp. 1--16. Jan, 2023.
Transgenic goats with cardiac-specific overexpression of constitutively active TGF-β1 (n = 14) underwent AF inducibility testing by rapid pacing in the left atrium. We chose a minimum of 10 minutes of sustained AF as a cut-off for AF inducibility. Explanted hearts underwent DTI to determine the fiber direction. Using tractography data, we clustered, visualized, and quantified the fiber helix angles in 8 different regions of the left atrial wall using two reference vectors defined based on anatomical landmarks.
Sustained AF was induced in 7 out of 14 goats. The mean helix fiber angles in 7 out of 8 selected regions were statistically different (P-Value < 0.05) in the AF inducible group. The average fractional anisotropy (FA) and the mean diffusivity (MD) were similar in the two groups with FA of 0.32±0.08 and MD of 8.54±1.72 mm2/s in the non-inducible group and FA of 0.31±0.05 (P-value = 0.90) and MD of 8.68±1.60 mm2/s (P-value = 0.88) in the inducible group.
DTI based fiber direction shows significant variability across subjects with a significant difference between animals that are AF inducible versus animals that are not inducible. Fiber direction might be contributing to the initiation and sustaining of AF, and its role needs to be investigated further.
Heart Position Uncertainty Quantification in the Inverse Problem of ECGI|
J.A. Bergquist, L.C. Rupp, A. Busatto, B. Orkild, B. Zenger, W. Good, J. Coll-Font, A. Narayan, J. Tate, D. Brooks, R.S. MacLeod. In Computing in Cardiology, Vol. 49, 2022.
Electrocardiographic imaging (ECGI) is a clinical and research tool for noninvasive diagnosis of cardiac electrical dysfunction. The position of the heart within the torso is both an input and common source of error in ECGI. Many studies have sought to improve cardiac localization accuracy, however, few have examined quantitatively the effects of uncertainty in the position of the heart within the torso. Recently developed uncertainty quantification (UQ) tools enable the robust application of UQ to ECGI reconstructions. In this study, we developed an ECGI formulation, which for the first time, directly incorporated uncertainty in the heart position. The result is an ECGI solution that is robust to variation in heart position. Using data from two Langendorff experimental preparations, each with 120 heartbeats distributed across three activation sequences, we found that as heart position uncertainty increased above ±10 mm, the solution quality of the ECGI degraded. However, even at large heart position uncertainty (±40 mm) our novel UQ-ECGI formulation produced reasonable solutions (root mean squared error < 1 mV, spatial correlation >0.6, temporal correlation >0.75).
Unipolar R:S Development in Chronic Atrial Fibrillation|
E. Paccione, B. Hunt, E. Kwan, D. Dosdall, R. MacLeod, R. Ranjan. In Computing in Cardiology, Vol. 49, 2022.
Past studies have examined the differences between R and S waves of unipolar atrial signals in patients with atrial fibrillation (AF) and have shown a difference in the R to S ratio (R:S) in certain regions of the atria compared to a healthy population. This work indicates a potential use of R:S as a marker for AF. In this study, we further examine these claims and investigate temporal changes in R:S over AF development in animals.
A Sliding Window Approach to Regularization in Electrocardiographic Imaging|
B.A. Orkild, J.A. Bergquist, L.C. Rupp, A. Busatto, B. Zenger, W.W. Good, J. Coll-Font, R.S. MacLeod. In Computing in Cardiology, Vol. 49, 2022.
Introduction: The inverse problem of ECGI is ill-posed, so regularization must be applied to constrain the solution. Regularization is typically applied to each individual time point (instantaneous) or to the beat as a whole (global). These techniques often lead to over- or underregularization. We aimed to develop an inverse formulation that strikes a balance between these two approaches that would realize the benefits of both by implementing a sliding-window regularization. Methods: We formulated sliding-window regularization using the boundary element method with Tikhonov 0 and 2nd order regularization. We applied regularization to a varying time window of the body-surface potentials centered around each time sample. We compared reconstructed potentials from the sliding-window, instantaneous, and global regularization techniques to ground truth potentials for 10 heart beats paced from the ventricle in a large-animal model. Results: The sliding-window technique provided smoother transitions of regularization weights than instantaneous regularization while improving spatial correlation over global regularization. Discussion: Although the differences in regularization weights were nuanced, smoother transitions provided by the sliding-window regularization have the ability to eliminate discontinuities in potential seen with instantaneous regularization.
The Role of Beta-1 Receptors in the Response to Myocardial Ischemia|
L.C. Rupp, B. Zenger, J.A. Bergquist, A. Busatto, R.S. MacLeod. In Computing in Cardiology, Vol. 49, 2022.
Acute myocardial ischemia is commonly diagnosed by ST-segment deviations. These deviations, however, can show a paradoxical recovery even in the face of ongoing ischemic stress. A possible mechanism for this response may be the cardio-protective effects of the autonomic nervous system (ANS) via beta-1 receptors. We assessed the role of norepinephrine (NE), a beta-1 agonist, and esmolol (ES), a beta-1 antagonist, in the recovery of ST-segment deviations during myocardial ischemia. We used an experimental model of controlled myocardial ischemia in which we simultaneously recorded electrograms intramurally and on the epicardial surface. We measured ischemia as deviations in the potentials measured at 40% of the ST-segment duration. During control intervention, 27% of epicardial electrodes showed no ischemic ST-segment deviations, whereas during the interventions with NE and ES, 100% of epicardial electrodes showed no ischemic ST-segment deviations. Intramural electrodes revealed a different behavior with 71% of electrodes showing no ischemic ST-segment deviations during control ischemia, increasing to 79% and 82% for NE infusion and ES infusion interventions, respectively. These preliminary results suggest that recovery of intramural regions of the heart is delayed by the presence of both beta-1 agonists and antagonists even as epicardial potentials show almost complete recovery.
Uncertainty Quantification of Cardiac Position on Deep Graph Network ECGI|
X. Jiang, J. Tate, J. Bergquist, A. Narayan, R. MacLeod, L. Wang. In Computing in Cardiology, Vol. 49, 2022.
Subject-specific geometry such as cardiac position and torso size plays an important role in electrocardiographic imaging (ECGI). Previously, we introduced a graph-based neural network (GNN) that is dependent on patient-specific geometry to improve reconstruction accuracy. However, geometric uncertainty, including changes in cardiac position and torso size, has not been addressed in network-based methods. In this study, we estimate geometrical uncertainty on GNN by applying uncertainty quantification with polynomial chaos emulators (PCE). To estimate the effect of geometric variation from common motions, we evaluated the model on samples generated by different heart torso geometries. The experiments shows that the GNN is less sensitive to heart position and torso shape and helps us direct development of similar models to account of possible variability.
Unexpected Errors in the Electrocardiographic Forward Problem|
A. Busatto, J.A. Bergquist, L.C. Rupp, B. Zenger, R.S. MacLeod. In Computing in Cardiology, Vol. 49, 2022.
Previous studies have compared recorded torso potentials with electrocardiographic forward solutions from a pericardial cage. In this study, we introduce new comparisons of the forward solutions from the sock and cage with each other and with respect to the measured potentials on the torso. The forward problem of electrocardiographic imaging is expected to achieve high levels of accuracy since it is mathematically well posed. However, unexpectedly high residual errors remain between the computed and measured torso signals in experiments. A possible source of these errors is the limited spatial coverage of the cardiac sources in most experiments; most capture potentials only from the ventricles. To resolve the relationship between spatial coverage and the accuracy of the forward simulations, we combined two methods of capturing cardiac potentials using a 240-electrode sock and a 256-electrode cage, both surrounding a heart suspended in a 192-electrode torso tank. We analyzed beats from three pacing sites and calculated the RMSE, spatial correlation, and temporal correlation. We found that the forward solutions using the sock as the cardiac source were poorer compared to those obtained from the cage. In this study, we explore the differences in forward solution accuracy using the sock and the cage and suggest some possible explanations for these differences.
αIIbβ3 integrin intermediates: from molecular dynamics to adhesion assembly|
D. Tong, N. Soley, R. Kolasangiani, M.A. Schwartz, T.C. Bidone. In Biophysical Journal, 2022.
The platelet integrin αIIbβ3 undergoes long range conformational transitions associated with its functional conversion from inactive (low affinity) to active (high affinity) states during hemostasis. Although new conformations intermediate between the well-characterized bent and extended states have been identified, their molecular dynamic properties and functions in the assembly of adhesions remain largely unexplored. In this study, we evaluated the properties of intermediate conformations of integrin αIIbβ3 and characterized their effects on the assembly of adhesions by combining all-atom simulations, principal component analysis, and mesoscale modeling. Our results show that in the low affinity, bent conformation, the integrin ectodomain tends to pivot around the legs; in intermediate conformations the upper headpiece becomes partially extended, away from the lower legs. In the fully open, active state, αIIbβ3 is flexible and the motions between upper headpiece and lower legs are accompanied by fluctuations of the transmembrane helices. At the mesoscale, bent integrins form only unstable adhesions, but intermediate or open conformations stabilize the adhesions. These studies reveal a mechanism by which small variations in ligand binding affinity and enhancement of the ligand-bound lifetime in the presence of actin retrograde flow stabilize αIIbβ3 integrin adhesions.
UncertainSCI: Uncertainty quantification for computational models in biomedicine and bioengineering|
A. Narayan, Z. Liu, J. A. Bergquist, C. Charlebois, S. Rampersad, L. Rupp, D. Brooks, D. White, J. Tate, R. S. MacLeod. In Computers in Biology and Medicine, 2022.
We developed and distributed a new open-source Python-based software tool, UncertainSCI, which employs advanced parameter sampling techniques to build polynomial chaos (PC) emulators that can be used to predict model outputs for general parameter values. Uncertainty of model outputs is studied by modeling parameters as random variables, and model output statistics and sensitivities are then easily computed from the emulator. Our approaches utilize modern, near-optimal techniques for sampling and PC construction based on weighted Fekete points constructed by subsampling from a suitably randomized candidate set.
Concentrating on two test cases—modeling bioelectric potentials in the heart and electric stimulation in the brain—we illustrate the use of UncertainSCI to estimate variability, statistics, and sensitivities associated with multiple parameters in these models.
UncertainSCI is a powerful yet lightweight tool enabling sophisticated probing of parametric variability and uncertainty in biomedical simulations. Its non-intrusive pipeline allows users to leverage existing software libraries and suites to accurately ascertain parametric uncertainty in a variety of applications.
Comparing different nonlinear dimensionality reduction techniques for data-driven unsteady fluid flow modeling|
H. Csala, S.T.M. Dawson, A. Arzani. In Physics of Fluids, AIP Publishing, 2022.
Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) is known for producing high-dimensional spatiotemporal data. Recent advances in machine learning (ML) have introduced a myriad of techniques for extracting physical information from CFD. Identifying an optimal set of coordinates for representing the data in a low-dimensional embedding is a crucial first step toward data-driven reduced-order modeling and other ML tasks. This is usually done via principal component analysis (PCA), which gives an optimal linear approximation. However, fluid flows are often complex and have nonlinear structures, which cannot be discovered or efficiently represented by PCA. Several unsupervised ML algorithms have been developed in other branches of science for nonlinear dimensionality reduction (NDR), but have not been extensively used for fluid flows. Here, four manifold learning and two deep learning (autoencoder)-based NDR methods are investigated and compared to PCA. These are tested on two canonical fluid flow problems (laminar and turbulent) and two biomedical flows in brain aneurysms. The data reconstruction capabilities of these methods are compared, and the challenges are discussed. The temporal vs spatial arrangement of data and its influence on NDR mode extraction is investigated. Finally, the modes are qualitatively compared. The results suggest that using NDR methods would be beneficial for building more efficient reduced-order models of fluid flows. All NDR techniques resulted in smaller reconstruction errors for spatial reduction. Temporal reduction was a harder task; nevertheless, it resulted in physically interpretable modes. Our work is one of the first comprehensive comparisons of various NDR methods in unsteady flows.